Home News Study Says Face Shields Not Safe for Others Than Regular Masks

Study Says Face Shields Not Safe for Others Than Regular Masks

Study Says Face Shields Not Safe for Others Than Regular Masks

Face shields and masks with exhalation valves were found to be less effective at protecting others from the coronavirus than normal face coverings, according to a study on Tuesday.

New research, published in the journal Physics of Fluids, determined that the two options, which some wearers find more comfortable — allowed ejected particles to escape, putting those around you in danger of being exposed to the virus.

The findings come amid an increasing trend of people replacing their regular cloth or surgical masks with clear plastic face shields, or masks equipped with exhalation valves.

“We observe that face shields are able to block the initial forward motion of the exhaled jet; however, aerosolized droplets expelled with the jet are able to move around the visor with relative ease,” according to the study by researchers at Florida Atlantic University. “There is a possibility that widespread public adoption of the alternatives, in lieu of regular masks, could have an adverse effect on ongoing mitigation efforts against COVID-19.”

The visual demonstration released on Tuesday showed how large plumes of particles can escape from behind a face shield or vented mask.

Researchers used a hollow manikin head to emulate a cough or sneeze by a pressure impulse applied to a manual pump. Tracers composed of droplets of distilled water and glycerin were expelled through the head and were visualized by the laser sheets to observe the illuminated path of the plume.

While the initial particles were blocked, the demonstration showed aerosolized particles swirling out from under the shield.

“Overall, the visuals presented here indicate that face shields and masks with exhale valves may not be as effective as regular face masks in restricting the spread of aerosolized droplets,” the study added.

Face shields typically have gaps along the bottom and the sides. They are used in the medical community primarily for protecting the wearer against incoming sprays and splashes while in close proximity to patients.

Air has to bend to go around the face shield, and smaller aerosol particles — believed to play a role in spreading the virus — follow the airflow around the shield, said Linsey Marr, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at Virginia Tech, according to the New York Times.

“It’s not going to splat,” Dr. Marr added.

Researchers also found that valve masks allowed a large number of particles to escape and that some of the nonmedical vented masks used had faulty valves.

The study didn’t observe what level of protection the shields and masks offered the wearer.

Similar demonstrators by the university examined the effectiveness of various facemasks in stopping the spread of respiratory jet. Poor or improper fitting of a normal cloth mask or N95 masks depicted a smaller puff of smoke jetting from the mask, however, the visualization showed that it was significantly more effective.

“Masks act as filters and actually capture the droplets and any other particles we expel,” said Siddhartha Verma, an assistant professor at Florida Atlantic University and the study’s lead author, according to the paper.

“Shields are not able to do that. If the droplets are large they will be stopped by the plastic shield. But if they are aerosol sized, 10 microns or smaller, they’ll just escape from the sides or the bottom of the shield. Everything that is expelled will very likely get distributed in the room.”

Meanwhile, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) said there “is not known what level of protection a face shield provides to people nearby from the spray of respiratory droplets from the wearer.”

“Therefore, CDC does not currently recommend use of face shields as a substitute for masks,” the agency said.


Eskalera, a Startup Led by Goldman Sachs’ Former HR Head Has Launched a Diversity and Inclusion Index

Eskalera, a technology startup led by Goldman Sachs former human resources head Dane Holmes, has launched an index to measure corporate diversity and inclusiveness,...

HSBC to Remove 35,000 Jobs Amidst Covid-19 Crises

HSBC Holdings Plc has restarted cutting as many as 35,000 jobs, three months after the coronavirus outbreak forced it to pause a long-awaited overhaul...

Genpact Offers Its Internal Skill Training Program Globally for Everyone

Genpact has announced Adapt and Rise, a role-based online learning platform that leverages Genpact's expertise honed from delivering real-world change for hundreds of clients....

San-Francisco Based Learning Platform Degreed Has Raised $32 Million in New Funding

The upskilling platform, Degreed, has announced $32 million in new funding in direct response to overwhelming demand for better skill insights, talent mobility, and...

Research Shows the Implications of Workplace Layouts on Employee Productivity and Overall Performance

As some workplaces prepare for the gradual return of employees and overhaul office layouts and seating plans, research has shown this could also have...

Employee Concierge ‘Back Technologies’ Integrates Automation Into Internal HR and Other Support Tasks

Companies are under increasing pressure to automate workflows and digitally service their employees, particularly in light of trends toward remote work. It takes an...

HR Strategies to Help Your Business Navigate the New ‘Normal’

No business is immune to the massive changes resulting from the health crisis. Organizations have proven themselves to be agile, and employees have demonstrated...

The Importance Of Diversity And Inclusion In HR, Hiring, Talent Management: Thoughts From A Top Expert

Michael C. Hyter is one of today’s best-known experts on inclusion and diversity and the author of The Power of Choice: Embracing Efficacy to Drive Your Career and The...

HR Expert Highlights Actionable Steps to ‘Make Real Change’ Against Racism in Your Workplace

Kyra Leigh Sutton, Ph.D., is a faculty member at the Rutgers University School of Management and Labor Relations, where she teaches human resources courses...

Adidas Employees Want Company to Investigate HR Chief for Response to Racial Issues

A group of Adidas employees from around the globe is asking the company to investigate its chief human resources officer, as part of a...