Home News 6th Cir. Lottery Pick a ‘Favorable’ Draw for OSHA Vaccine Mandate’s Challengers

6th Cir. Lottery Pick a ‘Favorable’ Draw for OSHA Vaccine Mandate’s Challengers

6th Cir. Lottery Pick a ‘Favorable’ Draw for OSHA Vaccine Mandate’s Challengers

News Brief:

  • The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has been selected via lottery to hear the multidistrict challenge to the Biden administration’s COVID-19 vaccination emergency temporary standard.
  • The 6th Circuit’s composition of active and senior status judges includes eight Democratic appointees and 20 Republican appointees. On Nov. 12, the 5th Circuit reaffirmed its stay of the Occupational Safety and Health Administration’s ETS.
  • In a statement following the Nov. 12 filing, OSHA said on its website that enforcement activity around the ETS would be effectively paused amid the proceedings. “While OSHA remains confident in its authority to protect workers in emergencies, OSHA has suspended activities related to the implementation and enforcement of the ETS pending future developments in the litigation.”

Rather than a coin flip, Tuesday’s outcome was determined — literally — by a ping-pong ball drawing. It is that kind of chance to which the ETS, one of the most notable measures taken in response to a public health crisis in U.S. history, is subject.

In reacting to the announcement, some attorneys following the lottery noted that the draw of the 6th Circuit could favor the mandate’s challengers.

“The Sixth Circuit is a favorable draw for mandate challengers, one of the best they could have hoped for,” Sean Marotta, partner at Hogan Lovells said in an email. “The court has many judges skeptical of broad assertions of agency authority, and this is their chance to cement that reputation. But the three-judge panel that may initially hear the case will be selected randomly and could be made up of a majority of Democratic appointees. It will just depend—again—on chance.”

Regardless of the ensuing hearing’s outcome, whichever side of the 6th Circuit’s decision loses is expected to appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

The Biden administration may be tasked with defending the ETS from conclusions drawn by the 5th Circuit in its most recent order reaffirming its stay. The court wrote that the ETS is both “overinclusive” and “underinclusive” in scope. “On the dubious assumption that the Mandate does pass constitutional muster—which we need not decide today—it is nonetheless fatally flawed on its own terms,” the 5th Circuit added.

Eskalera, a Startup Led by Goldman Sachs’ Former HR Head Has Launched a Diversity and Inclusion Index

Eskalera, a technology startup led by Goldman Sachs former human resources head Dane Holmes, has launched an index to measure corporate diversity and inclusiveness,...

HSBC to Remove 35,000 Jobs Amidst Covid-19 Crises

HSBC Holdings Plc has restarted cutting as many as 35,000 jobs, three months after the coronavirus outbreak forced it to pause a long-awaited overhaul...

Genpact Offers Its Internal Skill Training Program Globally for Everyone

Genpact has announced Adapt and Rise, a role-based online learning platform that leverages Genpact's expertise honed from delivering real-world change for hundreds of clients....

San-Francisco Based Learning Platform Degreed Has Raised $32 Million in New Funding

The upskilling platform, Degreed, has announced $32 million in new funding in direct response to overwhelming demand for better skill insights, talent mobility, and...

Research Shows the Implications of Workplace Layouts on Employee Productivity and Overall Performance

As some workplaces prepare for the gradual return of employees and overhaul office layouts and seating plans, research has shown this could also have...

Employee Concierge ‘Back Technologies’ Integrates Automation Into Internal HR and Other Support Tasks

Companies are under increasing pressure to automate workflows and digitally service their employees, particularly in light of trends toward remote work. It takes an...

HR Strategies to Help Your Business Navigate the New ‘Normal’

No business is immune to the massive changes resulting from the health crisis. Organizations have proven themselves to be agile, and employees have demonstrated...

The Importance Of Diversity And Inclusion In HR, Hiring, Talent Management: Thoughts From A Top Expert

Michael C. Hyter is one of today’s best-known experts on inclusion and diversity and the author of The Power of Choice: Embracing Efficacy to Drive Your Career and The...

HR Expert Highlights Actionable Steps to ‘Make Real Change’ Against Racism in Your Workplace

Kyra Leigh Sutton, Ph.D., is a faculty member at the Rutgers University School of Management and Labor Relations, where she teaches human resources courses...

Adidas Employees Want Company to Investigate HR Chief for Response to Racial Issues

A group of Adidas employees from around the globe is asking the company to investigate its chief human resources officer, as part of a...